1. Home
  2. Homeowners Insurance

Find the Best Homeowners Insurance in Columbus, WI

Homeowners have many options when it comes to choosing a broker or provider for homeowners insurance in Columbus. WiscNews has partnered with ConsumerAffairs to create this guide by comparing national ratings, local customer reviews and availability of more than 30 businesses and choosing seven favorites from the top home insurance companies in Columbus.

Companies pay ConsumerAffairs to be authorized, and WiscNews and/or ConsumerAffairs may receive compensation when you click a link, call a number or fill out a form on this site.

Take a Home Warranty Quiz

Get matched with an Authorized Partner

Compare Columbus Home Insurance Companies

What to know about homeowners insurance in Columbus

southern wisconsin skyline

Homeowners insurance isn’t required in Wisconsin, but if you have a mortgage, your lender likely requires it. Homeowners insurance protects residents from financial loss after damages to their dwelling and personal property due to fire, lightning, hail and windstorms, theft, and other events, known as “perils” in the insurance industry.

Homeowners insurance in Wisconsin also includes coverage for liability in case you are responsible for a nonauto-related accident on or off your property, medical payments of nonfamily members injured on your property and additional living expenses if you are forced out of your home because of a covered peril.

  • What homeowners insurance covers: A standard homeowners insurance policy covers your dwelling and detached structures, like garages and sheds; your personal property, including furniture and clothing; personal liability; medical payments; and additional living expenses. The perils that most homeowners insurance policies protect against include fire and smoke, lightning, windstorms, hail, the weight of ice or snow, vandalism, theft, glass breakage and falling objects.
  • What homeowners insurance doesn’t cover: Homeowners insurance doesn’t cover everything. Some events that are not covered under a standard home insurance policy include water damage from flooding or sewer backup, earthquakes and problems caused by neglect.

When you buy homeowners insurance in Columbus, you have the ability to choose coverage amounts and add on coverage such as flood insurance, sewer backup coverage and scheduled personal property coverage for high-value items including jewelry and antiques.

Before choosing a homeowners insurance policy, you should verify that the agent, broker or company you are working with is licensed in Wisconsin by the Office of the Commissioner of Insurance. Read over a policy carefully to make sure you understand the coverage; if you have questions, be sure to ask your agent or the insurance company.

Average home insurance costs in Wisconsin

The average cost of homeowners insurance in Wisconsin is between $1,000 and $1,100 per year, or about $83 to $92 per month. That is less than the average in most states across the U.S.

The cost of a particular homeowners insurance policy in Wisconsin depends on a number of factors:

  • Where in Wisconsin you live
  • The type of home you live in, including its building materials, age and size
  • The types of coverage you buy and the coverage limit amounts
  • Your deductible

Keep more than just cost in mind when choosing a home insurance company in Wisconsin. Read customer reviews, learn about the claims process, find out details about renewal and cancellation and research the company’s financial health before making your final decision.

How to save on homeowners insurance in Wisconsin

Everybody wants to know how to get cheaper home insurance. Here are some more tips to save on your premium:

  • Comparison shop. There are many homeowners insurance providers throughout the state. We recommend getting quotes from at least three companies. Similar policies can vary in price significantly between insurers.
  • Fix your credit. Most insurance companies factor your credit history into the cost of your policy. Improving your credit score can translate to lower rates. Check your credit report before getting a quote to make sure it is accurate.
  • Ask about discounts. Ask your insurance provider for a list of all the discounts it provides. Homeowners insurance discounts are common for new homeowners, claim-free customers, those who bundle home insurance with auto insurance and homeowners with security devices such as smoke detectors and alarm systems.
  • Choose actual cash value coverage over replacement value coverage. Actual cash value coverage reimburses you for loss or damage of personal property while taking depreciation into account. The reimbursement amount is typically lower than with replacement value coverage, which pays for the full cost of replacement at today’s prices.
  • Raise your deductible. Increasing your deductible will lower your premium.

Columbus homeowners insurance FAQ

How are homeowners insurance companies regulated in Columbus?

The Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance regulates homeowners insurance companies in Wisconsin. It issues licenses to entities that market and sell insurance in the state and reviews policies to make sure they comply with Wisconsin law.

What are the different types of homeowners insurance?

The main types of policies are broad form (HO-2), which lists covered perils for dwelling and personal property coverage; special form (HO-3), which lists excluded perils for dwelling coverage and names perils for personal property coverage; and comprehensive form (HO-5), which lists only exclusions for both types of coverage. There is also modified coverage form (HO-8), condominium insurance (HO-6), mobile home insurance (HO-7) and renters insurance (HO-4).

What do I need to get homeowners insurance online?

If you're looking to get home insurance online, you'll need to provide detailed information about you and your house. Be ready to give your name, date of birth and Social Security number. You also will need to know details about recent renovations and the age of certain home components and appliances. It’s also important to have an idea of how much coverage you need.

How is home insurance calculated?

The cost of home insurance in Wisconsin depends on your home’s characteristics (e.g., building material, square footage, age), where you live, the coverage you buy and your deductible. On average, home insurance premiums in Wisconsin are lower than in most of the U.S.

Can I get homeowners insurance without an inspection?

It may be possible to get homeowners insurance without an inspection if your home is new or the insurance company recently did an inspection for the previous owner.

Do you have to have home insurance?

You are not legally required to have home insurance in Wisconsin, but if you have a mortgage, your lender will likely require it.

Columbus home insurance company information


Lemonade offers homeowners insurance across most of the country. By providing information about yourself and your home, you can receive a quote and complete your application online. If you have safety features installed in your home, such as burglar alarms, fire extinguishers and deadbolts, you may qualify for a discount.

Lemonade Learn More


EverQuote is a free online insurance marketplace that connects consumers to quotes from leading insurance companies. Customers provide information and start receiving prices within minutes. EverQuote has handled over 35 million quote requests, according to its website.



Allstate homeowners insurance policies cover personal property, dwellings and legal liability. You can apply online, by phone or in person with a local agent, but you need to provide information about yourself, your home and your property. Agents can help you choose the right level of coverage. Allstate has agents throughout Wisconsin, including an office at 1460 W. Main St., Ste. 140, Sun Prairie, WI 53590.

Allstate Learn More

Farmers Homeowners Insurance

Farmers insures over 10 million households across all 50 U.S. states with coverage of homes, vehicles and more. Columbus customers can choose from Standard, Enhanced or Premier plans and customize coverage. Benefits include the Declining Deductibles feature and the Claims Free Discount. A local Farmers agency is at 1020 N. Bristol St., Ste. 201, Sun Prairie, WI 53590.

Farmers Homeowners Insurance Learn More

State Farm

State Farm is one of the most popular insurers in the country, with more than 84 million policies in force. The company offers discounts for bundling home and auto coverage, having home alert protection and using impact-resistant roofing products. Get a quote online or see local agent Dave Maylone at 156 W. James St., Columbus, WI 53925.

State Farm

Anton Insurance

Anton Insurance is an independent insurance agency in Columbus. Call or stop by the office for a free, no-obligation quote. Agents can show you how to qualify for multiple discounts. Anton Insurance is located at 137 W. Mill St., Columbus, WI 53925.

Anton Insurance


Travelers has been in business over 165 years and is one of the leading writers of personal insurance in the U.S. Featured discounts include the multipolicy discount, homebuyer discount, claim-free discount and protective device discount. Check out the Travelers website to get a quote on homeowners insurance or to locate an agent in Columbus.