1. Home
  2. Mattress Brands

Find the Best Mattress Stores in Beaver Dam, WI

If you’re looking to purchase a new mattress, you have options, from where to buy the mattress to the mattress material to size. It’s important to do plenty of research before making a decision. WiscNews has partnered with ConsumerAffairs to create this guide by comparing customer reviews and product selection of 25 businesses and choosing nine favorites from the top mattress companies in Beaver Dam.

Companies pay ConsumerAffairs to be authorized, and WiscNews and/or ConsumerAffairs may receive compensation when you click a link, call a number or fill out a form on this site.

Compare Beaver Dam Mattress Brands

Types of mattresses in Beaver Dam

beaver dam skyline

When choosing a type of mattress in Beaver Dam, you have several factors to consider:

  • Firmness: Some sleepers prefer the support of a firm mattress, while others like the feel of a soft option.
  • Materials: Mattresses are made out of a variety of materials. You can find materials that are organic, eco-friendly and hypoallergenic if that’s what you’re seeking.
  • Sleeping position: Certain mattresses are better for some sleep positions than others. For instance, those who sleep on their stomach may need the support of a firmer mattress.

Shoppers can choose from the following common mattress types in Beaver Dam:

  • Latex mattresses are made from either natural or synthetic latex and usually include anywhere from two to four layers of material. In addition to being a comfortable choice, this mattress type is good for those searching for a hypoallergenic or environmentally friendly option.
  • Gel-infused foam mattresses are memory foam mattresses that infuse gel beads into the foam layer. As a result, the mattress contours to the body shape and absorbs motion. It is ideal for those looking to eliminate disturbances caused by motion on a traditional mattress.
  • Innerspring mattresses are an affordable mattress type utilizing a grid of interconnected coils covered by padding to create support. As a result, the mattress reduces motion transfer disturbances.
  • Memory foam mattresses are an allergen-resistant option for those allergic to other mattress materials. They are ideal for sleepers looking to minimize aches and pains, as the mattress forms around the body for a heightened level of comfort.
  • Hybrid mattresses usually consist of springs covered by at least one layer of foam. This combination provides the benefits of both a memory foam mattress and a spring mattress.

Bed-in-a-box companies vs. mattress stores in Beaver Dam

Choosing a mattress company in Beaver Dam involves deciding between an online, bed-in-a-box company and an in-store mattress retailer. Each type of mattress company offers advantages and disadvantages. Both options provide customers a variety of mattress types and sizes to choose from.

Benefits of mattress stores Drawbacks of mattress stores
  • Try a mattress before buying
  • In-person assistance
  • Multiple mattress brands
  • Exclusive in-store discounts and sales promotions
  • Limited returns, refunds and exchanges
  • Higher prices
  • Possible sales pressure

Many mattress customers have shopped with mattress-in-a-box companies in recent years.

Benefits of online mattress brands Drawbacks of online mattress brands
  • Shop from your own home
  • Often less expensive
  • Free shipping and returns
  • Long sleep trials
  • No testing out mattress before purchasing
  • Limited setup and mattress removal services

How much do mattresses cost in Beaver Dam?

Mattresses in Beaver Dam can range in price from $200 to $2,000 or more based on a variety of factors. These factors include:

  • Mattress size: As the mattress sizes increase, so does the price. Understandably, a California king mattress costs much more than a twin mattress.
  • Mattress type: Newer and eco-friendly material types tend to have a higher price tag.
  • Mattress brand: Luxury mattress brands carry higher prices. Fortunately, there are many affordable mattress brands on the market.
  • Shipping/delivery fees: While some companies offer free shipping or delivery, others require a fee. Some online and in-person mattress companies also offer expedited shipping and delivery for an extra charge.
  • Discounts and promotions: Look for mattress companies that offer discounts and promotions to reduce the overall cost of the mattress.

Beaver Dam mattress customers should shop at mattress companies that offer lengthy sleep trials, options for returning or exchanging a mattress, and long-lasting warranties. The Federal Trade Commission recommends getting copies of these policies in writing.

Beaver Dam mattress stores FAQ

How long does a mattress last?

A mattress usually lasts between seven and 10 years with the right care. Latex is widely thought to be the most durable mattress material and can last even longer.

How much does a bed in a box cost in Beaver Dam?

The cost of a mattress in a box varies based on the size and material type. Bed-in-a-box mattresses can range from $350 to $2,000 or more.

What are the standard mattress sizes?

In order from smallest to largest, standard mattress sizes include:

  • Twin
  • Twin XL
  • Full
  • Queen
  • King
  • California king

Most mattress companies offer options ranging from twin to king, while some companies also offer crib and California king sizes.

How do I dispose of my mattress in Beaver Dam?

The City of Beaver Dam picks up bulk waste, including mattresses and box springs, twice per year, in May and October. You can also drop off a mattress for disposal on two days each month on Myrtle Road.

Beaver Dam mattress company information


Saatva sells mattresses online. It offers mattresses with different firmness levels, along with adjustable bed bases. Customers have a 180-day trial to ensure they are satisfied with the mattress. The company offers free white-glove delivery service with setup and removal of your old mattress. Financing at 0% over six months is available for qualified customers at the time of publishing.

Saatva Shop Now

Cocoon by Sealy

Cocoon by Sealy is an online mattress company with a variety of memory foam and hybrid mattress types and sizes, along with pillows and adjustable bed bases. All mattresses come with a 10-year limited warranty and free shipping. Beaver Dam residents can get 0% financing at the time of publishing with a Cocoon by Sealy credit card.

Cocoon by Sealy

Brentwood Home

Brentwood Home sells mattresses delivered in boxes to customers' front doors. Choose from hybrid, memory foam, natural and latex mattresses. The company offers financing through Affirm. It also offers free shipping, a one-year trial period and free returns. Mattresses come with a 25-year warranty. Brentwood Home also sells bedding and yoga products.

Brentwood Home


Leesa sells its mattresses online and in select stores. Mattresses come in a variety of materials and sizes and can be purchased with adjustable bed frames and other mattress accessories. Leesa offers a 100-night trial and free delivery. Each mattress comes with a 10-year warranty. For every 10 mattresses sold, Leesa donates a mattress to a child in need.


Avocado Mattress

Avocado Mattress is an online mattress company. The company specializes in handmade organic mattresses and also offers pillows, bedding and other furniture. It sells mattresses for cribs, California kind bed frames and every size in between. Financing is available from Affirm. Each mattress includes a one-year trial and a 25-year limited warranty.

Avocado Mattress

Nest Bedding

Nest Bedding is an online mattress company with showrooms in select states. The company sells hybrid, latex and other types of mattresses. Customers can take advantage of the 100-night trial to determine if the mattress is right for them. Shipping is free for Beaver Dam customers. Bedding and furniture products are also available for purchase.

Nest Bedding Shop Now


Kohl’s is a department store that sells mattresses from a variety of brands, including Sealy and Serta. Customers can purchase a mattress in-store or online and pick up the mattress in-store or have it shipped. Mattress warranties are available based on the manufacturer’s policy. Kohl’s is located at 1734 N. Spring St., Beaver Dam, WI 53916.



Slumberland sells hybrid, innerspring and memory foam mattresses from a variety of brands, along with bedding, pillows and bed frames. It offers local delivery for free, while full-service delivery is offered for an additional $99.99 at the time of publishing. Slumberland’s local store is at 1645 N. Spring St., Beaver Dam, WI 53916.


Verlo Mattress

Verlo Mattress operates multiple stores around the country and offers mattress types including memory foam and innerspring. The company also sells adjustable beds and foundations. Verlo mattresses come with a lifetime guarantee. Financing is available. The local Verlo Mattress store is at 1613 N. Spring St., Beaver Dam, WI 53916.

Verlo Mattress